Tennessee men’s basketball players and Athletes.org have put together a proposal for what collective bargaining could look like in college sports. It covers compensation, transfers, health care, academic opportunities, and other parts of the athlete experience.
Before we get too far, though, one distinction matters. This is not a collective bargaining agreement.
Credit to Matt Brown of Extra Points, whose November 13 article, “When is a CBA not actually a CBA?”, provides valuable context for understanding that distinction. Athletes.org’s published term sheet and announcement provide the details behind the proposal.
What Tennessee’s Players Actually Put Together
Tennessee’s players elected representatives who worked with Athletes.org to develop their priorities and discuss them with athletics leadership. The result is a proposed term sheet outlining subjects that a future agreement could address.
Athletes.org explicitly states that it is neither a signed agreement nor a ratified CBA. Its summary also clarifies that Tennessee’s administration has not agreed to or endorsed the terms. Participating in the discussions does not establish a university commitment to implement them.
The proposal includes:
A compensation structure that pays players for athletic services, replacing the patchwork of revenue sharing and university-affiliated NIL agreements.
A salary cap paired with a spending floor and minimum player compensation.
Financial incentives for performance and remaining with a program.
Guaranteed compensation during injury, extended medical coverage, and independent mental health resources.
Negotiated transfer rules, limits on athletic commitments, and an independent grievance process.
Support for completing a desired degree when athletic obligations interfere with pursuing that major.
Those last few items deserve attention. Athletes have interests beyond the size of their next payment. They also have bodies, academic goals, families, and futures that extend beyond their playing careers. Giving them a meaningful role in identifying those priorities is useful, even before an enforceable agreement exists.
The Framework Still Needs a Path to Implementation
Brown’s central caution is that developing proposed terms does not resolve the legal questions necessary to make collective bargaining work. Who employs the athletes? Who represents them? Which institutions participate? What makes the resulting agreement enforceable?
Brown also discusses Tennessee athletic director Danny White’s proposed centralized employer model and the legal skepticism surrounding it. Those questions remain consequential. A productive exercise cannot, by itself, establish the employment and bargaining structure needed to implement its ideas. I think we can recognize that limitation while still seeing value in the conversation.
The proposal gives athletes and administrators something specific to examine. It also makes the trade-offs visible. If schools want compensation limits and predictable roster rules, what protections and benefits are they prepared to negotiate in return? That is a more useful discussion than simply asking athletes to accept whatever structure administrators believe will restore stability.
When Do We Start Writing Different Rules?
For me, this proposal raises a bigger question about the direction of college athletics.
If the leading football and basketball programs want salary structures, negotiated player movement, performance bonuses, and professional roster management, when do we start designing rules around the business they are choosing to operate? How much of the amateur model do those programs actually want to retain?
Power Four football and men’s basketball are the obvious places to begin that discussion, although conference membership alone would be an imperfect dividing line. Major basketball programs outside the Power Four would need consideration, too. The point is to acknowledge that different sports and programs have different financial realities and educational purposes. A commercial model built around major football should not automatically determine what makes sense for a swimmer, a Division III soccer player, or a smaller Division I athletic department.
Different Rules Must Include Responsibility
Separate rules cannot simply become permission for the wealthiest programs to keep more money while everyone else absorbs the consequences. Any serious proposal should address support for women’s and Olympic sports, educational access, and the financial relationships connecting programs within athletic departments. Moving the biggest commercial operations into a different structure would require deliberate protections for the broader system.
But continuing to organize the entire industry around their demands carries its own risks. If every solution assumes that everyone else must spend more, travel more, and reorganize their programs to accommodate the biggest brands, we should question how sustainable that approach is. Tennessee’s exercise has not solved collective bargaining. It has, however, helped put concrete priorities on the table.
Now the conversation needs to get bigger. We should be asking what a workable agreement requires, which programs need a different operating model, and how to protect the athletes whose opportunities could otherwise become collateral damage. College athletics serves too many students for its future to be designed exclusively around its most expensive teams.

